Jewish Temperament

Understanding temperament through the prism of Chassidus and Kabbalah

Category: Right-Artisan

Personalities: Avraham

by Zalman

The forefathers are referred to as a merkavah, a chariot for G-d, meaning that every step they took was in complete accordance with G-d’s will. This was possible because their entire self was entirely dedicated to G-d. This, however, didn’t detract from their particular personalities, and it is for this reason that each of the forefathers represent a different spectrum of G-d’s attributes, directly corresponding to their own temperament.

What’s more, the Gemara states that all Jewish people possess three qualities: humility, empathy, and generosity. These qualities are inherited from the forefathers, with each one contributing a different quality. It turns out that each of the forefathers specifically contributed the quality that most represented their own temperament.

Avraham is famously cited in Chassidus as representing the right path — meaning the expansive path — of the sefirot, which include chochmah, chessed, and netzach. There is even a midrash that states that G-d’s attribute of chessed complained that it has nothing to do since Avraham entered the world. In this way, Avraham was an Artisan, embodying such traits as tactical intellect and creativity in action, generosity, impact, influence, spontaneity, audacity and boldness. Let’s take a look:

Tactical intellect and creativity in action: Avraham famously manipulated and strong-armed people into blessing G-d, by giving them meals and lodging in middle of the desert, and then charging them exorbitant prices for these services. For his guests, the only way out of paying was for them to bless G-d. To Avraham, the thought and emotion of the guest didn’t matter much, it was the action of blessing that was deemed important.
Another anecdote well expressing Avraham’s tactical intellect was when he taught his city about G-d… by destroying his father’s entire inventory of idols and fabricating an elaborate tale to prove his point. He claimed that the idols had begun fighting over who should receive an offering he had presented them. The largest idol, Avram claimed, had picked up a hammer and smashed the lot of them. His point? Idols cannot see, hear, speak, or think, much less protect their worshipper. The aftermath of this spectacle highlighted another aspect of Avraham’s expansive temperament, as we shall see.

Generosity: One need not search long for Avraham’s generosity. His home was famously open in each direction, to welcome in wayfarers. He would treat all with the utmost hospitality, no matter their origins or beliefs. The Torah recounts that he once slaughtered three choice calves to serve three guests whom he’d never met previously.
When Avraham heard that his estranged nephew Lot had been captured in an epic battle, he magnanimously set off to rescue him. Upon return from battle, Avraham declared that he would not take even a shoelace from the spoils, rather he would give them back to the captives.
Later in life, after the Torah testifies that “G-d had blessed Avraham with everything,” Avraham signed away every last of his possessions to his son, Yitzchak, to give him a better chance at marrying the right girl.

Impact and influence: Avraham was widely recognized in his time as a leader of the generation. This was in part due to his elaborate displays of faith, which included many miracles, as well as his talking to and convincing others, authoring and publishing books on monotheism, and more.
After Avraham’s miraculous salvation from a fiery furnace, he convinced an entire city of idolaters, the infamous Nimrod among them, to accept Hashem as the only true G-d.
When Avraham threw a party for his newborn son, Yitzchak, all the Kings, noblemen and leaders of the period were there to celebrate with him. When Avraham expressed his intent to purchase a field from a commoner, his people immediately promoted him to a position of honor.

Spontaneity: Virtually everything Avraham did was spontaneous. He destroyed his father’s idols, and as a result was thrown into a fiery furnace. Mind you, this was even before G-d had revealed Himself to Avram, promising to protect him. Avram up and left his house on a moment’s notice, even though he had no idea of the destination. He circumcised himself at ninety nine years of age. The Torah is specific in describing Avraham’s eagerness and hastiness in fulfilling G-d’s command — waking up early in the morning, and saddling his donkey — even if that meant slaughtering his own son.
Yes, many of these were at the behest of G-d. However, first of all, G-d didn’t specify that Avram act with haste and seeming spontaneity. And besides, the fact that G-d asked Avraham to do these things, and not someone else, emphasizes how temperamentally suited to these tasks Avraham was.

Audacity and boldness: Many of the points we mentioned already describe Avraham’s audacity. The fact that he was alone in his beliefs, completely against the prevalent tide. As a mere youth, he faced off against the most powerful person of his time, Nimrod, daring him to punish Avram for his “errant” beliefs. Avraham went to battle against four mighty armies with but a handful of servants, a tactical plan, and some sand.

In the end, Avraham is the most obvious representation of what we know as the Artisan, the expansive type, and it is therefore fitting that we inherit from him the wonderful attribute of generosity.

Temperaments: Artisan

by Zalman

According to Chassidus, each of the four temperaments can be described entirely with a single overarching term, which for the Artisan is expansion. As such, when we dig deeper into the Artisan’s personality, we discover that this specific term describes its every aspect. The many aspects of personality are divided in Chassidus into three primary categories; those being intellect, personal disposition (i.e., with regard to oneself), and relational disposition (i.e., in the context of others). So, in short, if we were to categorize the Artisan, we would find that his intellect, personal disposition, and relational disposition are all expansive.

The Artisan’s intellect is Chochmah — expansive intellect. Chassidus goes to great lengths to describe what exactly Chochmah is. Here are some of the highlights: Chochmah is quick, sudden, and impactful. It doesn’t last long. It cannot be stimulated through active thought, rather it strikes an emptied mind, giving birth to something entirely new. Intellect at that level is not comprehensible, which means that it’s not really an idea or theory. This describes what Keirsey calls tactical intellect, that is, intellect of action. It’s the intellect of the athlete, the performer, the virtuoso, the one who does or says exactly the right thing at exactly the right time with the exact mix of grace and velocity to have the most impact. The intellect of the Artisan best translates into their art, in the broad sense of the term, to also include arts like athletics, culinary, literary, and more.

The Artisan’s personal emotion is that of Chessed — expansive personal disposition. The quality of Chessed is that which wishes to have an impact, as big as possible, on as much as possible. To “own” everything, to touch everything. Because of their unbounded Chessed, Artisans tend to be excited in the present, optimistic about the future, and uncaring about the past. They want to live as large as possible, in the here and now. It is this quality which also lends to the Artisan’s impulsive pleasure-seeking (see Tanya ch. 1), even if not in line with society’s (or in this case, Torah’s) directives. On the other hand, this also lends itself to the Artisan’s great generosity, always giving, always impulsively, without thought for himself.

The Artisan’s relational emotion is Netzach — expansive relational disposition. When found within the context of others, Netzach is the quality that competes, perseveres, and emerges victorious, despite the obstacles in the way. It is due to this quality that nothing can inhibit the Artisan, and in fact, the Artisan will specifically spite boundaries and inhibitions, which bears their quality of audacity and boldness. This also applies to people: the Artisan will manipulate others for their own purpose, and even bypass them entirely if they are deemed unhelpful. With the right purpose, this quality serves the Artisan’s life-mission, as we’ll see below (Divine Purpose).

* * *

The Artisan in Judaism

Hero: Avraham Avinu

Symbol on the Merkavah: Lion

Davening Meditation: Contemplating the greatness of G-d through the wonders of creation. When we realize how amazing the universe is, from the celestial bodies to the minutest organism, and by G-d’s word all work in perfect tandem to produce the result we see around us, we can appreciate the greatness of G-d Himself. But it doesn’t stop there. As Chassidus teaches, creation is but G-d’s word, only a sliver’s sliver of radiance from His essential being. From this we recognize not only the infinitesimalness of the universe in G-d’s eyes, but the unfathomable enormity of G-d’s omnipresence, and we are driven to bring G-d into every moment of our lives.

Divine Purpose: The Artisan’s strength lies in positive manipulation of others, which, on a motivational level could be called inspiration. Depending on their specific role-variant, Artisan’s have an uncanny ability to inspire people and/or manipulate objects for their purpose. The purpose of the Artisan, then, is to use this ability to further disseminate G-d’s presence in the world. To uplift people with their infectious excitement and inspire them to appreciate G-d and His Torah, as Avraham did. To infuse all manner of physical objects with G-dliness, from cow-hide in a Mezuzah to wool in Tzitzis. From food on the Shabbos table to dropping a coin in the Tzedakah box. And this includes bigger things as well, like establishing a school or building the biggest Shul in town. Everything the Artisan touches should turn into gold of goodness.

Learning Torah through pshat: acquiring a piece of information. Artisans tend to like their Torah delivered practically, and in bite sizes. That includes halachos, mishnayos, and the like, as well as more “fun” areas, like history, aggadah, midrash, and cute vertlach. Additionally, of all the types, Artisans may be the best memorizers. In the context of Torah, they can memorize words, halachos, mishnayos, mesechtas, etc. They also memorize concepts and ideas, sugyos, shakla ve’taryas, etc. Artisans are not into asking deep or divisive questions; they aren’t as interested in understanding the material, as they are in knowing it. And once they have acquired new information, Artisans will hold it until it can be used, much like a tool, in the most impactful way. Interesting tidbit: Artisans often learn better when they are simultaneously doing or playing with something tangible.

Vocation: For an Artisan, there are times when Judaism can be a bit overbearing, what with all its rules and regulations. However, the Torah knows who we are and it has designated a significantly large part to Artisans.
To begin with, many Artisans go into business, especially entrepreneurship, earn money, and make great contributions to their chosen institutions. Wherever you may reside, almost all of the well-known major contributors to local institutions are, in fact, Artisans.
Judaism has always had a special place for art, especially speaking, music, and poetry, which Jewish people have engaged in throughout the ages. This becomes even truer now, when the Jewish music scene is just getting started. Not to mention Jewish visual art, which has produced quite a few talents in recent history.
Judaism also has a few obviously kinesthetic vocations, such as safrus and shechita.
In the past hundred or more years, a new industry has blossomed, which is an aspiring Jewish Artisan’s heaven. That industry is known by many as shlichus, to others as kiruv. Shluchim thrive on inspiration, and that’s exactly what they deliver to their constituents. They require impact, every moment of every day. The schedule is spontaneous and in many situations, they need to think on their feet. If there’s any place an Artisan can be successful, Shlichus is definitely a good one.

Jewish Temperament Theory

by Zalman

Over the past century, as the fields of the behavioral sciences exploded in breadth and reach, there has been a relatively quiet revolution growing parallel. The underlying premise behind this revolution is that there are a specific number of personality types, and every person is born to be a single type. Once we understand which type a given person is, most, if not all, of his behaviors, attitudes, and even thinking methods, can be explained by his temperament, and at times even anticipated.

This is the study of human temperament.

Loosely speaking, this revolution was widely popularized by Isabel Briggs-Myers’ Myers-Briggs Type Indicator. Once it was published, people the world over were clamoring to find out “who they were”. More recently, Myers’ work was brought to a completely new level, in structure and application, by a preeminent psychologist, David Keirsey. In his book, Please Understand Me II, Keirsey not only polished the theory and made it more understandable and accessible, he also made it more scientific. While Myers had 16 types, Keirsey divided them into 4 basic types. While Myers based her Indicator on the theoretical work of Carl Jung, Keirsey based his work on 60+ years of observing people. While Myers tried to deduce thought and emotion, Keirsey established observable phenomena. And, most importantly, while Myers’ types fluctuate in their applicability, Keirsey’s remain consistent throughout the spectrum.

After studying the work of Dr. Keirsey, it becomes eminently apparent that the ideas he lays forth are to be found within the depth of Chassidic wisdom. Here, we will attempt to uncover many of the relationships between sage Chassidic teachings and modern-day personology.

It starts with the four temperaments: Artisan, Guardian, Idealist, and Rational. Each of these types are extremely different in every aspect of personality, from intellect to language; from interests to orientation; from self-image to values. We will explore the four types in depth, but for now, let’s suffice with a short list of descriptive words for each.
The Artisan is described by Keirsey as being tactical, optimistic, artistic, audacious, excited, impulsive, and generous.
The Guardian is considered logistical, dependable, beneficent, respectable, concerned, authoritative, and grateful.
The Idealist is diplomatic, mystical, empathic, benevolent, authentic, enthusiastic, intuitive, and romantic.
Finally, the Rational is strategic, pragmatic, relativistic, ingenious, autonomous, purposeful, resolute, calm, and abstract.

Chassidic doctrine is punctuated by Kabbalah’s famous 10 Sefirot, from Chochmah to Malchus. However, if we were to compact the sefirot into what are called kavim, or paths, we would discover that there are but four general categories:
The right path, expansion, represented by Chochmah, Chessed, and Netzach.
The left path, contraction, represented by Binah, Gevurah, and Hod.
The center path, unification, represented by the Da’as, Tiferes, and Yesod.
Malchus, abstraction, also in the center, without its own distinct qualities to speak of.

When viewing the Sefirot in this light, the correlations become obvious (compare the following terms with those describing the temperaments above):
The Artisan expands, like the right path of the spectrum, which include Chochmah (expansive intellect), Chessed (expansive personal disposition), and Netzach (expansive relational disposition). Some terms to describe these sefirot would be: creative, generous, optimistic, competitive, and audacious.
The Guardian contracts, representing the left path of the Sefirot, which include Binah (contractive intellect), Gevurah (contractive personal disposition), and Hod (contractive relational disposition). Words that describe these sefirot might include: logistical, respectable, concerned, beneficent, and grateful.
The Idealist, representing the center path, unifies with Da’as (unifying intellect), Tiferes (unifying personal disposition), Yesod (unifying relational disposition). These sefirot may be described with words like: intuitive, mystical, kind, empathic, and romantic.
The Rational represents Malchus, which is not as much a path as it is a single abstract point. Malchus also represents expression, primarily through speech, and can be described with words such as: abstract, purposeful, and relativistic.

It can be seen, then, that with Chassidus, we have a wealth of relevant information on personology that we may not have seen before. Everything described here is yet brief. And as we explore these themes even more in depth, we find more and more correlations between Chassidic teachings and the modern understanding of temperament. Not only that, but Chassidus also adds a level of purpose and meaning to an otherwise dry, if accurate, study of personality. With Chassidus we understand the purpose of knowing ourselves, and the consequent self-improvement journey we should embark on once we find out.